Methodology

The readiness ladder

Five gates, each with a question it must answer. A gate combines a reviewer's judgement against five criteria with a calibrated evidence test, so progress reflects what has actually been verified.

Reading the ladder

Readiness is not an investment decision

Gate status measures how complete and verified an opportunity's information is. Every investment decision rests with the capital provider's own investment committee.

Open this example report
The five gates

What each gate asks, and the criteria the reviewer assesses.

Each criterion is assessed as met, partly met, not met or validated N/A. A level where everything is N/A cannot pass.

L1Commercial Potential

Is there a real problem, a paying customer and a plausible model worth spending diligence on?

Conditional pass needs at least 70% of applicable P1 items cleared; below 40% the gate is not ready.

  • 1.1Opportunity can be described in one paragraph (what, who pays, why)
  • 1.2Problem and customer are real (not a theoretical market)
  • 1.3Plausible economic equation / unit economics
  • 1.4Sponsor identity and entity verified
  • 1.5No obvious fatal flaw (legal, sanctions, reputational, jurisdictional)
L2Development Readiness

Are site, rights, technology and structure secured well enough to justify development spending?

Conditional pass needs at least 80% of applicable P1 items cleared; below 50% the gate is not ready.

  • 2.1Site / land / resource / operating rights secured by the right entity
  • 2.2Technology or operating model proven at pilot / relevant scale
  • 2.3Feasibility or business case completed
  • 2.4Operating / project entity (SPV) exists and is correctly structured
  • 2.5Funding requirement built bottom-up and reconciled to the headline ask
L3Investment Readiness

Could an investor complete diligence and price the risk?

Conditional pass needs at least 90% of applicable P1 items cleared; below 60% the gate is not ready.

  • 3.1Reviewed financial model with registered assumptions
  • 3.2Demand / revenue evidence at modelled price (contracts, LOIs, history)
  • 3.3Governance, KYC, COI and cap table clean
  • 3.4E&S baseline (ESIA / ESMS) in place or scheduled as a CP
  • 3.5Material risks allocated with identified instruments
L4Financing Readiness

Can lenders and investors issue term sheets and take it to credit or IC?

Conditional pass needs at least 95% of applicable P1 items cleared; below 75% the gate is not ready.

  • 4.1Capital stack defined with named counterparties
  • 4.2Security / credit-enhancement package agreed in principle
  • 4.3Independent technical / legal / model review complete
  • 4.4Offtake / revenue contracts executed or in final form
  • 4.5Insurance, hedging and tax position confirmed
L5Financial Close Readiness

Are all conditions precedent satisfied so capital can be disbursed?

Conditional pass needs at least 100% of applicable P1 items cleared; below 90% the gate is not ready.

  • 5.1Financing agreements agreed / executed
  • 5.2All CPs satisfied and evidenced
  • 5.3Board / shareholder / regulatory approvals obtained
  • 5.4Accounts, waterfall and reserve accounts established
  • 5.5Management representation letter delivered
How a gate is decided

Two tests, one outcome.

The judgement test is the reviewer's assessment of the five criteria. The evidence test counts applicable priority-one items cleared, critical gaps, open RED assumptions, enforceability and bankability items, structurally fatal items and, from Level 2, the capital reconciliation. The final gate status combines both.

GatePass: P1 completeConditional: P1 completeConditional: max criticalConditional: max RED assumptionsConditional: max enforceability o/sConditional: max bankability o/sNot ready belowCapital exception blocks Pass
L1 · Commercial Potential100%70%322340%No
L2 · Development Readiness100%80%221250%Yes
L3 · Investment Readiness100%90%111160%Yes
L4 · Financing Readiness100%95%000175%Yes
L5 · Financial Close Readiness100%100%000090%Yes

Calibration is governance-controlled. Thresholds tighten as an opportunity climbs: by Level 4 no critical items or RED assumptions may remain for a conditional pass.

Gate outcomes

Seven possible results.

PASS

All applicable P1 items cleared; judgement PASS; no critical, fatal, unanswered-HIGH, RED or unmitigated-high-risk items; capital reconciled where required.

CONDITIONAL PASS

May progress subject to defined CPs: completion and critical/RED/enforceability/bankability counts within the level calibration above.

HOLD

Material evidence gaps remain; progression pauses pending resolution.

NOT READY

Structurally fatal item unresolved, judgement FAIL, or completion below the NOT READY floor.

EXCEPTION

Proceeds only with explicit IC / senior approval (approver independent of the deal lead, dated, with rationale). Computed outcome remains visible.

NOT ASSESSED

Criteria incomplete, or fewer than three criteria substantively assessed (all-N/A levels cannot pass).

RE-ASSESS

Lifecycle stage has changed since the last gate review (Profile B24 ≠ B15): every gate is suspended until the reviewer re-assesses.

Progression

How an opportunity moves up the ladder.

Level achieved

The highest level for which every lower gate has passed.

Achieved conditionally

The highest level reached with a pass, a conditional pass or an IC-approved exception at each lower gate. Conditions are tracked as actions.

Next institutional action

Generated from the next gate to clear: what is outstanding, who owns it and when it is due.

  • Capital tests by gate. L2: ask numeric, requirement built, ask reconciles, contingency. L3: + no unevidenced CE substitution. L4: + identified funding and risk-mitigation covered. L5: + committed funding, no over-funding.
  • If the lifecycle stage changes after a gate review, every gate is suspended until the reviewer re-assesses. Items that were not yet applicable re-activate automatically.
  • An exception needs a dated approval, with rationale, from someone independent of the deal lead. The computed outcome stays visible alongside it.